Supreme Court's under-18 ruling triggers fresh debate on teen sexuality

The Supreme Court DH File

As per Section 375 of the IPC, which defines rape, sex with a woman under the age of 18 is a criminal offence.

Meenakshi Ganguly, South Asia Director for Human Rights Watch, said the court decision would help ending the practice of early marriages. In our opinion, sexual intercourse with a girl below 18 years of age is rape regardless of whether she is married or not", the court said adding: "The exception carved out in the IPC creates an unnecessary and artificial distinction between a married girl child and an unmarried girl child and has no rational nexus with any unclear objective sought to be achieved. "While it is true that 18 years is accepted as the age of consent, it is also true that adolescents exploring their sexuality should not be deemed criminals", she said.

Referring to the IPC and the POCSO Act, the apex court said there was a visible conflict between the two laws with regard to the sexual assault on girl child aged between 15 to 18 years.

Marriages of girls are prevalent in India, especially among the rural poor. "The artificial distinction is discriminatory and is definitely not in the interest of the girl child". It said if a married girl was over 15 years of age, her husband could not be charged with any offense. The minor wife can now file a rape complaint within a year of the alleged crime, though the verdict will not apply to the past cases. The issue of criminalisation of marital rape is pending before the High Court of Delhi and it will be interesting to what extent the decision of the Supreme Court has a bearing on the outcome in that case.

Interestingly, although the court has categorically stated that it is not dealing with the larger issue of marital rape, Justice Madan B Lokur has held that "Constitutionally, a female has equal rights as a male and any theory that propounds a constitutional myth to the contrary must be demolished." .

Highlighting the inconsistencies in various laws, the Supreme Court on Wednesday also touched upon separate marriage laws for Hindus and Muslims and said the provisions make a "mockery" of the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act (PCMA).

"I am not oblivious to the harsh reality that most of the child brides are even below the age of 15 years". Despite improvement in literacy levels, child marriages are still common in different parts of the country. "They are innocent children, who do not even understand what marriage is", Justice Gupta wrote.

Though child marriage is prohibited, it is not automatically void under India's civil laws. She has to do this within two years of attaining majority, that is by the time she is 20 years old.

The court slammed the government for trying to "somehow legitimise" the exception clause. The government had argued that the "practice of child marriage can not be wished away and, therefore, legislature in its wisdom has thought it fit not to criminalise the consummation of such child marriages".

Providing a harmonious and purposive interpretation to all statutes relating to the rights of child, the bench has adopted an approach that best secures the interest of the girl child and further protects her fundamental right to liberty, equality, and dignity, the bench has held that Exception 2 to Section 375 of the IPC must be read down to read that "Sexual intercourse and sexual acts by a man with his own wife, the wife not being under the age of 18, is rape".

Related News:

  • Smith pays tribute to Passchendaele soldiers

    Smith pays tribute to Passchendaele soldiers

    Today marks 100 years since 846 Kiwi soldiers lost their lives in the Battle of Passchendaele as they passed through Ypres. There was a ceremonial welcome from the Maori Cultural Group of the New Zealand Defence Force.
    Williams-Sonoma, Inc. (WSM) Raised to Buy at Zacks Investment Research

    Williams-Sonoma, Inc. (WSM) Raised to Buy at Zacks Investment Research

    TheStreet upgraded shares of Williams-Sonoma from a "c+" rating to a "b-" rating in a research report on Monday. (NYSE:WSM). According to Zacks, "Williams-Sonoma enjoys a competitive advantage owing to its multi-brand/multi-channel business model".
    Pitt QB Browne has season-ending shoulder surgery

    Pitt QB Browne has season-ending shoulder surgery

    DiNucci will be the starter for now but since Pickett's redshirt is burned, look for Narduzzi to get him playing time. He'll face off with NC State on Saturday as he tries to help Pitt dig out of a 2-4 start to the season.
  • Pakistan violates ceasefire in J&K's Poonch, third provocation in 24 hours

    Pakistan violates ceasefire in J&K's Poonch, third provocation in 24 hours

    Following the heavy shelling by the Pakistani side, the schools in Digwar sector have been asked to remain shut. The spokesperson said Reddy was a courageous and sincere soldier and Zahir was an honest and dedicated worker.
    Local scouting community reacts to Boy Scouts changes

    Local scouting community reacts to Boy Scouts changes

    In Western New York, the Girl Scouts serve about 15,000 girls and there are 21,000 total members including adults, she said. A press release from the Girl Scouts of Western New York states the organization is against the idea.

    Lam Research Corporation (LRCX) PT Raised to $215.00

    BidaskClub upgraded Lam Research Corporation from a "hold" rating to a "buy" rating in a research report on Wednesday, July 12th. Parus Finance (Uk) Limited has invested 1.38% in QUALCOMM, Inc. (NASDAQ:ADSK) shares were sold by BEVERIDGE CRAWFORD W .
  • Father of Baby Girl Found in Woods Charged With Murder

    Father of Baby Girl Found in Woods Charged With Murder

    WSB reported that as police searched the child, McNabb walked into a convenience story and told a clerk that he "didn't do it". According to reports, before he was charged in connection with the case, McNabb had been telling people that he didn't do it.
    SC issues guidelines for designation of senior lawyers

    SC issues guidelines for designation of senior lawyers

    The Full Court may also recall the senior designation of a lawyer if it feels he is guilty of conduct that disentitles him to the same.

    Lions' Haloti Ngata out for season with torn bicep

    Although the 33-year-old can still be reinstated from injured reserve in eight weeks, the injury is likely to be season-ending. Jones, a former first-round pick for the Packers, spent four years in Green Bay, where he tallied 73 tackles and nine sacks.
  • Stock Rating Update on the Shares of Delcath Systems Inc (DCTH)

    To measure price-variation, we found DCTH's volatility during a week at 8.08% and during a month it has been found around 17.4%. PetMed Express, Inc. (PETS) pays a dividend of 0.80, which translates to dividend yield of 2.24% based on the current price.
    Nawaz Sharif to skip court proceedings in Panama Papers case today

    Nawaz Sharif to skip court proceedings in Panama Papers case today

    She stayed at the home of her son-in-law, which is located on The Mall, rather than going to her Jati Umra residence. Kulsoom, who is suffering from throat cancer, has undergone three surgeries in the United Kingdom so far.
    'Fair chance' of Lemar leaving Monaco in 2018, Vasilyev concedes

    'Fair chance' of Lemar leaving Monaco in 2018, Vasilyev concedes

    He's very important to our team. 'You never want to make any major changes in January, except something really extraordinary'.


Most liked

Arrested Indian fishermen by Sri Lankan Navy sent for police remand
Sri Lanka Navy on Wednesday has handed over 6 more Indian fishing trawlers back to India, having made repairs to them. Detention of Indian fishermen by Lankan authorities is frequent, as they often cross the worldwide maritime boundary.

Under-fire Arena addresses US future: 'I'll do whatever is right'
While fans fulminated over the front office, the next national team coach must instigate a ruthless roster purge. Open Cup titles and the team has made the playoffs every season since 2011. "This has been coming for a while".

Reinsurance Group of America, (RGA) Earning Positive Media Coverage, Study Finds
On average, equities research analysts forecast that Reinsurance Group of America, will post $10.22 EPS for the current year. The stock of Reinsurance Group of America Inc (NYSE:RGA) has "Hold" rating given on Thursday, July 27 by Wells Fargo.

Which Insider sold 50000 Shares Of Vishay Intertechnology, Inc. (VSH)?
The firm earned "Outperform" rating on Friday, February 19 by Credit Suisse. (NASDAQ:NUVA) on Tuesday, June 6 with "Buy" rating. Other large investors also recently bought and sold shares of the company. 39 funds opened positions while 76 raised stakes.

Family "Heartbroken" After Woman Found Dead In Belfast
The PSNI said tonight that it had been asked to issue the following statement from the Conlon family. In a statement , relatives of the Belfast woman say she was "a very independent person".

Berkshire Hathaway (NYSE:BRK-B) Valuation According To Analysts
More interesting news about Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (NYSE:BRK.A) earned "Buy" rating by Barclays Capital on Wednesday, August 12. Berkshire Hathaway Inc.is a holding firm owning subsidiaries engaged in various business activities.

Tom Brady 'not worried' about shoulder injury; will play in Week 6
When asked about whether there was concern over the offensive line play, Brady praised his unit. "I love that group up front". The Patriots did not include Brady on last week's injury report, and they were not required to.

Analysts See $1.62 EPS for Norfolk Southern Corp. (NSC)
ValuEngine raised Norfolk Souther Corporation from a "hold" rating to a "buy" rating in a research note on Friday, September 1st. The stock of Oaktree Capital Group LLC (NYSE:OAK) has "Buy" rating given on Monday, May 29 by Keefe Bruyette & Woods.

Mukul Roy quits RS, Trinamool
Roy, who has been cozying up to BJP leaders for some time now, admitted that he was in constant touch with them. Roy also held a meeting with finance minister Arun Jaitley last week.

Suspect Killed After Opening Fire on Alabama Police Officers
The Alabama Law Enforcement Agency will conduct the investigation, which also is standard procedure. Investigators have learned that the two vehicles in the parking lot were owned by the suspects.

Watch Katy Perry Coordinate An Epic Onstage Marriage Proposal
While Becky laughed and put her hands up to her mouth in shock, Katy jumped up and squealed: "Say yes, Becky , if you want to get married!" "My wish came true", said Katie .

South Alabama upsets Troy in the Battle for the Belt
Troy redshirt senior RB Jordan Chunn (undisclosed) rushed for 28 yards on 10 carries in Wednesday's 19-8 loss to South Alabama . Cole Garvin is completing 53.2 percent of his passes for 447 yards, two touchdowns and two interceptions.

Analyst EPS Predictions Coverage: Global Blood Therapeutics Inc. (GBT)
Equities analysts predict that Global Blood Therapeutics Inc will post ($2.55) earnings per share for the current fiscal year. The analysts, on average, are forecasting a $57.45 price target, but the stock is already up 146.82% from its recent lows.

Stephen Curry would select Warriors teammates for All-Star Game
If that rule were in place past year , Curry and LeBron James would have served as team captains. Green exclaims. "They don't come out and hit twenty-four threes and they're swept".

NeNe Leakes dropped from Xscape Tour after rape joke
They both have had successes outside the show and will meet again on the next season that premieres on November 5th. If NeNe does not comply, her 'conduct exposes you to multi-million dollar liability'.