USA justices rule Israeli victims can not sue terror-financing Arab Bank

Supreme Court rules foreign corporations can't be sued for alleged abuses under alien tort law

Victims of attacks in Israel can not use an 18th century law to sue the Arab Bank, a multinational financial institution, the US Supreme Court ruled on Tuesday in a precedent-setting case for other foreign businesses.

The Arab Bank was founded in Jerusalem in 1930 when Palestine was under the British Mandate, and now has more than 600 branches worldwide.

In his opinion for the Court, Kennedy emphasized that the question of ATS corporate liability raises serious foreign policy considerations best left to the political branches, noting this particular case has adversely affected the US relationship with Jordan, "a critical ally in one of the world's most sensitive regions".

The lawsuits invoked one of the first laws ever passed by Congress, the Alien Tort Statute of 1789, known as ATS, meant to be a forum for resolving claims of piracy.

The 5-4 decision left in place a lower court ruling that had thrown out a lawsuit brought by some 6,000 plaintiffs, including survivors and relatives of non-U.S. citizens killed in attacks, filed under a 1789 USA law called the Alien Tort Statute that accused Arab Bank of being the "paymaster" to militant groups.

Writing for the conservative majority in the decision posted Tuesday, Justice Anthony Kennedy said that US courts were too remote from the actions involved to rule.

The case decided today, Jesner v.

The U.S. Supreme Court decided on Tuesday to reject a complaint by Israeli terror victims against the Arab Bank of Jordan, one of the largest banks in the Arab world, which alleged that the bank provided financial services to terror organizations. Moreover, the justices added, the court should generally refrain from creating or extending new grounds for lawsuits, especially when dealing with a subject, like the ATS, that may create foreign-policy concerns and is therefore more properly dealt with by Congress and the executive branch. Gorsuch stressed that "the decision to impose sanctions in disputes between foreigners over global norms" belongs to Congress and the president, rather than the courts.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote a dissent, which was joined by fellow liberal Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer and Elena Kagan. Sotomayor castigated her colleagues for absolving "corporations from responsibility under the ATS for conscience-shocking behavior". The correct answer is that Congress, not the courts, should decide.

"The Court holds that foreign corporations may not be defendants in suits brought under the ATS", he wrote.

Click for vote alignment by ideology.

Related News:

  • Switch hacked through unpatchable exploit

    Switch hacked through unpatchable exploit

    The company then could ban those systems from using the Switch's online functions. But Nintendo is not completely powerless in the situation.
    Trudeau calls van attack 'horrific and senseless,' says no apparent terror link

    Trudeau calls van attack 'horrific and senseless,' says no apparent terror link

    In Toronto , Canadian rapper Maestro Fresh Wes returned Tuesday to the scene of the rampage, pausing by a newly erected memorial. Alce, an Ottawa native, said he moved to Toronto about 20 years ago, drawn by the city's peaceful atmosphere and lack of crime.
    Netanyahu 'Not Impressed' By Iranian Foreign Minister's Words

    Netanyahu 'Not Impressed' By Iranian Foreign Minister's Words

    Tehran blamed Israel and vowed unspecified retaliation, drawing Israeli counter-threats to broaden attacks on Iranian military assets in Syria.
  • Gary Neville explains who should be next Arsenal manager

    Gary Neville explains who should be next Arsenal manager

    And the former Gunners star responded to the question as to whether he's ready to make the step up to Arsenal. Chelsea was also humbled out of the Champions League against La Liga giants Barcelona in the Round of 16.
    Xiaomi Mi 6X to launch today: Expected specifications and features

    Xiaomi Mi 6X to launch today: Expected specifications and features

    What's more, the smartphone will come with a USB Type-C port and will support Qualcomm's Quick Charge 3.0 fast charging standard. The Xiaomi Mi 6X will be announced tomorrow in China, as a direct successor to the Mi 5X which was announced about a year ago.
    Bills unlikely to trade for Giants' No. 2 pick in NFL Draft

    Bills unlikely to trade for Giants' No. 2 pick in NFL Draft

    The Browns then traded that No. 8 in 2016 to move down again and wound up with Corey Coleman at No. 15 in 2016. If it's Allen at No. 1 and Darnold at No. 3, the Denver Broncos wouldn't let him slide past the No. 5 pick.
  • Mining baron G Janardhana Reddy brother gets BJP ticket

    Mining baron G Janardhana Reddy brother gets BJP ticket

    The sitting MLA BB Chimanakatti was denied a ticket and the Congress originally declared Devraj Patil as its Badami candidate. Vijayendra will not be contesting from the constituency against Yathindra Siddaramaiah, the chief minister's son.
    United States  mulls Adm. Harris as new amb. to South Korea

    United States mulls Adm. Harris as new amb. to South Korea

    Foreign Minister Julie Bishop said she had been informed of the decision by Acting Secretary of State John Sullivan on Tuesday. Opposition defense spokesman Richard Marles said the sooner Australia got a new US ambassador the better.
    Quetta rocked by third explosion, more casualties feared

    Quetta rocked by third explosion, more casualties feared

    It was not clear whether the third bomber was wearing an explosive vest or if the bike was filled with explosives. Some eight paramilitary officials were wounded in this attack, he added.
  • Herdsmen kill two priests, 11 others in Benue

    Herdsmen kill two priests, 11 others in Benue

    PRESIDENT Muhammadu Buhari has described as despicable and satanic the gruesome murder of Catholic Priests and worshippers at St. Ignatius Catholic Church in Ukpor -Mbalom community in Gwer East Local Government of Benue State .

    National Retail Properties (NNN) Given Daily Coverage Optimism Score of 0.05

    Finally, Municipal Employees Retirement System of MI raised its stake in National Retail Properties by 1.1% in the first quarter. Several other hedge funds and other institutional investors have also added to or reduced their stakes in the company.
    Resale price growth still rising in metro Denver, report says

    Resale price growth still rising in metro Denver, report says

    Portland-area home prices topped their housing bubble-era peak in August 2016 and have since climbed another 20 percent. USA home prices jumped in February as buyers competed fiercely over a dwindling number of properties for sale.


Most liked

The newest royal baby weight more than sibling George and Charlotte
The royal baby remains fifth in line of succession after Prince Charles, Prince William , Prince George and Princess Charlotte . It looks like Charlotte is totally owning her place in line for the throne.

Ranbir Kapoor Claims He's 'Boring,' Potential Biopic Will Be 'Very Existential'
Salman Khan starrer Race 3 and Ranbir Kapoor starrer Sanju both the films are coming to release in June month. Writer Abhijat Joshi said, "With Sanju , I have seen Hirani's art and craft evolve into something richer".

Lloyds Banking Group PLC (LLOY) Receives Average Rating of "Buy" from Analysts
A simple moving average is an indicator that calculates the average price of a security over a specified number of periods. ANALYSTS VIEWS: The current analyst consensus rating clocked at 4 on company shares based on data provided from FINVIZ .

Fresh Nokia X6 render leaks and (surprise!), it has a notched display
Though the LED flash is now placed symmetrically between the rear camera and the fingerprint sensor. The phone is expected to have dual SIM slot and is expected to come preinstalled with Android 8.1.

Iran threatens to withdraw from NPT if US scraps 2015 nuclear deal
Shamkhani made the remarks at a press conference before his departure to Russia's Sochi to attend an global security conference. Zarif said for fifteen months Trump has tried to sabotage the accord by disrupting normal business with Iran.

Past five months have been a nightmare, says Meek Mill
The sentence came against the recommendation of the prosecutor, who said Mill had matured since his original crime. Meek Mill was released from prison Tuesday after the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ordered his immediate release.

Why it's unlikely there will be a statewide teacher strike in Colorado
The wave of teacher activism reflects a national movement that has seen strikes, walkouts, and marches in West Virginia, Oklahoma, Arizona, and Kentucky.

Which insiders are trading Eli Lilly and Company (LLY)?
Eli Lilly and Company registered $21.75 million net activity with 0 insider purchases and 8 insider sales since December 11, 2017. Comparing the number of shares sold short to the float is a method analysts often use to get a reading on investor sentiment.

Louisiana governor, senators to attend Trump state dinner
Inquiring minds wondered what kind of statement the first lady sought to make with her attire. Edwards is expected to be one of the only Democratic officials at the state dinner.

Antonio Callaway's agent confirms diluted sample at Combine
If prospects were judged exclusively on their ability to play football, Callaway would likely be regarded as a first-round pick. It is now increasingly interesting to see what team will be willing to give Callaway yet another chance to prove himself.

Rocking Stocks: Merck & Co., Inc. (NYSE: MRK), Micron Technology, Inc. (NASDAQ: MU)
It fall, as 94 investors sold MRK shares while 631 reduced holdings. 558 grew holdings while 123 funds bought holdings. Credit Agricole S A has invested 0.01% in Merck & Co., Inc. (NYSE: MRK ) on Thursday, May 25 with "Sell" rating.

Salman Khan shoots in Sonamarg for Race 3
The judge granted permission on the condition that Salman informs the court of all details of his travel and stay overseas . While Shilpa Shetty had publicly apologized for hurting the sentiments, the case is still going on in the court.

China's Didi To Foray into Mexico
Didi Chuxing, founded in June 2012, has over 400 million users in China and more than 7,000 employees. Lyft , the second largest US ride services firm, does not have a formal design group, either.

A Higher Loyalty or New Lows?
It never ceases to amaze me how far someone will go to defend President Donald Trump , our idiot-in-chief. Ruffin's spokeswoman Michelle Knoll confirmed to Politico that Trump used the aircraft for his trip.

H1-B spouse visa threat
He added that companies may find it difficlt to retain such high skilled talent if the proposal goes through. PTI reports that so far, more than 100,000 H-4 visa holders have been beneficiaries of this rule.