Scientists Discover Bees Understand the Concept of Zero

The study raises the question of how a species that differs so much from humans - with fewer than one million neurons in its brain, compared to a human's 86,000 million neurons - can share such a complex skill.

When scientists showed the bees a blank image, the insects flew towards it. Bees also understood that zero was at the lower end of a sequence of numbers.

"Zero is a hard concept to understand and a mathematical skill that doesn't come easily - it takes children a few years to learn", the study's co-author Adrian Dyer, associate professor at Melbourne's RMIT University, said in a press release.

"We've long believed only humans had the intelligence to get the concept, but recent research has shown monkeys and birds have the brains for it as well".

A new study finds that untrained honey bees have the intellectual capacity to understand the abstract concept that zero has value. "What we haven't known - until now - is whether insects can also understand zero".

In passing this test, honey bees have shown the research team that they have a primitive grasp of an abstract mathematical concept.

RMIT PhD researcher Scarlett Howard set out to test the honeybee on its understanding, marking individual honeybees for easy identification and luring them to a specially-designed testing apparatus.

The insects soon learned to determine that two was smaller in two vs three elements and three was smaller in three vs four elements. They lured a few honeybees, which are seen as a ideal model for insect cognition, into the apparatus and trained them to choose the image that had the lowest number of elements.

The true surprise came to Howard when she realized that the bees began to fly to the blank card and not the one that was printed with a symbol, proving that they understood that zero holds a place on the number line.

'This is a tricky neuroscience problem, ' Dyer said.

Dyer, a researcher in the Bio Inspired Digital Sensing-Lab (BIDS-Lab) in RMIT's Digital Ethnography Research Centre, said the findings opened the door to new understandings of how different brains could represent zero.

Most of us - scientists included - thought only humans and other animals with big brains could grasp the concept of zero.

That said, as zero forms the core of maths and binary code, the researchers think that the neural model mechanics in bees could be used in the development of robotics and machine intelligence.

The number zero has an integral role in mathematics and many algebraic structures.

"Their brains are probably processing information in a very clever [i.e., efficient] way" Dyer said. Large brains are thus not necessary to play with numbers.

Related News:

  • The Queen's Birthday Parade: Best Photos

    Today's ceremony was also the first royal outing for Meghan Markle , Duchess of Sussex , since she returned from her honeymoon. While the Windsor kids are often oblivious of the throngs below, it can be intimidating, especially for adults.

    President Trump says he "probably" would support states' rights marijuana reform

    Along with Washington , D.C., nine states made recreational marijuana legal - among them California, Colorado, and Oregon. The legislation would ensure states have the right to determine the best approach to marijuana within their borders.
    US Cuts Deal With Chinese Smartphone Maker ZTE, Despite Opposition From Senators

    US Cuts Deal With Chinese Smartphone Maker ZTE, Despite Opposition From Senators

    US Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross defended the new agreement, saying in a statement: "We will closely monitor ZTE's behavior". This would allow the United States to quickly re-instate the ban if ZTE violates the terms of the 10 year agreement.
  • Tensions Run High at G7 Summit

    Tensions Run High at G7 Summit

    Waving banners, lighting flares and setting flags alight, protesters from various groups marched through the city for two hours. Officials have conceded the mood at the summit will likely be exceptionally tense.
    Man Says He Intentionally Contracted HIV Just To Infect Others

    Man Says He Intentionally Contracted HIV Just To Infect Others

    He was also found guilty on eight counts of viewing or distributing child pornography and meth possession. An Arkansas man admitted to purposely contracting HIV so he could infect others with the virus.
    Emirates has plans to fly windowless aircraft in future

    Emirates has plans to fly windowless aircraft in future

    Emirates chose to fix this problem for first class flyers by removing real windows completely. But aviation regulator European Aviation Safety Agency disagreed.
  • Merkel expects a 'difficult' G7 meeting

    Merkel expects a 'difficult' G7 meeting

    Merkel calmly replied that "in an exceptional humanitarian situation, Germany behaved very responsibly". "But I'll be back". The new format was put in place by the coalition that took office in March.
    LeBron James' farewell game as a Cavalier? Go behind the scenes

    LeBron James' farewell game as a Cavalier? Go behind the scenes

    But the weight of having to shoulder so much of the load throughout the Playoffs seemed to catch up with James in Friday's finale. Lue, of course, hopes James decides to stay. "I'm going to be his biggest fan in there with what he's able to do".
    Savannah Phillips Prince George Trooping the Colour celebrations

    Savannah Phillips Prince George Trooping the Colour celebrations

    The event was attended by other senior royals including the Queen , Prince Charles and the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge . Colours, or flags, were carried, or "trooped", down the rank so that they could be seen and recognised by the soldiers.
  • Anthony Bourdain's death impacts local community

    Anthony Bourdain's death impacts local community

    Idaho's suicide prevention advocates are gearing up for the 4th Annual Western States Conference on Suicide. Or for global folks, a list of crisis centers can be found here .
    No evidence of any foul play in Bourdain death

    No evidence of any foul play in Bourdain death

    We here at Food52 are heartbroken to have lost such a talent today, one who's taught us so much over the years. She wrote in a message on Twitter: "Anthony gave all of himself in everything that he did".
    Buffett, Dimon say quarterly profit forecasts harming economy

    Buffett, Dimon say quarterly profit forecasts harming economy

    Warren Buffett and Jamie Dimon have teamed up to once again call for the end to quarterly earnings guidance by companies. Dimon has blasted excessive reporting requirements and the short-term focus of quarterly earnings.

Most liked

Quebec ticket takes Friday night’s $60M Lotto Max jackpot
In case you're unfamiliar with the process, Lotto Max draws happen every Friday, and tickets cost $5 each. Lottery players can check their numbers on the Winning Numbers page on or on the OLG Lottery App.

Cavaliers owner deletes tweet about foul discrepancy at halftime of Game 3
Irving was traded to the Boston Celtics over the summer, and Cleveland has struggled to find enough offensive firepower to match up with Golden State without him.

Origin Access Premier service lets subscribers play full PC games before release
In addition, Origin Access Premier subscribers will still get the 10-percent discount on any Origin purchase they make. Anthem , a social, connected Action-RPG with cooperative multiplayer at its heart.

Facebook launches, its videogame streaming hub practically consolidates whoever you follow (or might want to follow) into one centralized section of the domain. Tech companies have been chipping away at Twitch's lead in the streaming industry for some time now.

Love Island contestants trying to make sense of Brexit is riveting television
You could literally tell Eyal didn't want to pick Hayley but he had to so Adam could pick out of Kendall or Rosie'. You may be familiar with a current television phenomenon known as Love Island .

Anil Kapoor wishes Sonam Kapoor a happy birthday with this throwback pic
Shashanka Ghosh's film " Veere Di Wedding " took the box-office by storm right from day one. "But I hope it would be", she said. The photograph doesn't present Sonam in the way we know her today.

Trump reportedly isn't happy about coming to Canada tomorrow
She said Canada , however, will not change its mind about the US steel and aluminum tariffs which she termed "illegal". Macron's office said the meeting would be held later Friday afternoon.

Meghan Markle and Prince Harry attend Trooping the Colour at Buckingham Palace
After the ceremony the royal family will head back to Buckingham Palace and gather on the balcony to watch the RAF flypast. The event was attended by other senior royals including the Queen, Prince Charles and the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge .

Jack Ma's Ant Financial Valued Around $150 Billion After Funding Round
The exercise amounted to the largest confirmed single fundraising round in history, according to data provider Crunchbase. Ant Financial is the world's highest-valued private technology startup, surpassing ride-sharing firm Uber Technologies.

Jean-Pierre Bemba: Congo warlord's conviction overturned
Bemba, the son of a businessman, became rich during years of close association with former Congolese leader Mobutu Sese Seko. He said Bemba would probably go to Belgium to meet with his family there before returning to Congo after he is released.

New Socialist Spanish Govt. Dominated by Women
But appointing Borrell, who is strongly opposed to Catalan independence, sends the opposite message. A novelist became culture minister and a former astronaut assumed the position of science minister.

Jennifer Lopez Reveals What Could End Her Relationship with Alex Rodriguez
Rodriguez makes sure to show his support towards her as well! This week, fans finally learned why she left the show. On Wednesday, she turned up at late-night show Jimmy Kimmel Live! and was open about her child's behaviour.

Former garbo to make shock Wallabies debut
Veteran flyhalf Johnny Sexton was relegated to the bench to allow Joey Carbery to start a test match for just the third time. It caps a remarkable rise for Paenga-Amosa, who was playing club rugby in Sydney this time a year ago .

Paladins confirmed for Switch release next week
Paladins will run at 60 fps and will allow cross play between the Switch and XBox One versions of the game. A first-person, multiplayer shooter has been confirmed for the Nintendo Switch.

Trump Administration Seeks to Gut Obamacare’s Protections for People With Pre-Existing Conditions
The administration said it agrees with Texas that the so-called individual mandate will be unconstitutional without the fine. The major difference is that the justice department, under Donald Trump , has largely switched sides.