Judge rules glyphosate cancer cases can move forward

Judge rules glyphosate cancer cases can move forward

A USA judge in San Francisco says evidence seems weak that Roundup weed killer causes cancer, but experts can still make that claim at trial.

The decision by U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria in San Francisco followed years of litigation and weeks of hearings about the controversial science surrounding the safety of the chemical glyphosate, the key ingredient in Monsanto's top-selling weed-killer. Monsanto is a unit of Bayer AG.

In response to Chhabria's ruling, Monsanto Vice President Scott Partridge noted the judge excluded some of the plaintiffs' experts and called the opinions of those he is allowing to testify "shaky".

The herbicide came under increasing scrutiny after the France-based International Agency for Research on Cancer, which is part of the World Health Organization, classified it as a "probable human carcinogen" in 2015.

"The scientific evidence is overwhelming that Glyphosate-based products do not cause cancer and did not cause Mr. Johnson's cancer", said Monsanto's defense attorney, George Lombardi.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency last September concluded glyphosate is likely not carcinogenic to humans.

The outcome of Johnson's case will not affect the hundreds of other lawsuits in state and federal courts, but it may serve as an indicator of how the others might go.

The company had told Chhabria in March that none of the plaintiffs' experts satisfied scientific or legal requirements for admissibility and urged the judge to dismiss the cases.

"We look forward to taking the next step - getting our clients their day in court", he said in a statement.

She said: 'It's time to hold Monsanto accountable for putting this unsafe product on the market'.

The lawsuits allege that glyphosate, the herbicide in the widely used Roundup, can cause non-Hodgkin's lymphoma - and that Monsanto didn't warn consumers or regulators about that alleged risk.

This case is a separate one from a class-action suit that involves more than 300 plaintiffs who argue that their exposure to Monsanto's weed killer caused them to also develop non-Hodgkin's lymphoma.

Related News:

  • Mutinous migrants land in Italy after threatening to kill their rescuers

    France has taken in a much smaller share of migrants in recent years than neighboring Germany or Italy . Italy's transport minister said some migrants made death threats against the crew.

    Engineered Cancer Cells Can Fight Cancer, Brigham And Women's Researchers Find

    The specially engineered tumor cells were made with a "kill switch' that would kill them after they presumably killed the tumor". The development of novel prevention and treatment strategies has dramatically improved cancer survival rates.
    Microsoft takes on Slack with free version of Teams

    Microsoft takes on Slack with free version of Teams

    Upgrading to the paid version also gives you more storage, enterprise security and compliance, and an unlimited number of users. Integrated, real-time content creation with Office Online apps, including built-in Word, Excel, PowerPoint, and OneNote.
  • BBC's 12 highest earners are all men

    BBC's 12 highest earners are all men

    It catapulted the broadcaster into turmoil, with respected China editor Carrie Gracie resigning over unequal pay. Evans takes in between £1.66-£1.67, while Irish chatshow host Graham Norton earns between £600,000 - £609,000.
    Trump demands increase in military spending

    Trump demands increase in military spending

    Merkel bristled at the idea that the gas deal has left her country "captive" to Moscow. Germany now spends about 1.2 percent, while the USA spends about 3.6 percent.
    Emily Ratajkowski debuts massive engagement ring

    Emily Ratajkowski debuts massive engagement ring

    She also revealed a few details about the ring, including the fact that the couple had designed it together. In two photos posted on her Instagram account, you can see the double diamond ring on full display.
  • President Trump loses 300K followers in Twitter purge

    By contrast, former President Barack Obama's count fell by 2.1 million followers, or 2.1 percent, to 101.5 million. Some celebrities lost the equivalent of a city's or even a small nation's worth of followers in mere minutes.

    NASA Burned Up Proof of Mars Life 40 Years Ago

    However, in 1976, NASA " s twin Viking landers conducted the first experiments that searched for organic matter on the Red Planet. Chris McKay is a scientist at NASA's Ames Research Center (Silicon Valley) and the lead author of the study.

    How to Ask a Question in the App's Stories

    The updates have increased since Instagram incorporated stories into the app like those on Snapchat, its competitor. Instagram Stories now includes a question sticker so nosy friends can quiz you on your posts.
  • NASA needs backup plan as USA crew launches slip

    Pictured here is the SpaceX Dragon cargo craft, a human-rated version of which is being developed to bring astronauts to space. NASA has been paying Russian Federation up to $82 million a seat to ferry U.S. astronauts to and from the ISS.

    Nicki Minaj gives Cardi B $5,000 gift basket for baby Kulture

    We also called the store, and an employee confirmed neither Nicki nor anyone on her team bought any items from them. Cardi is a mom for the first time while Offset has now added a fourth child to his family tree.
    Germany to extradite former premier Carles Puigdemont for misuse of public funds

    Germany to extradite former premier Carles Puigdemont for misuse of public funds

    Puigdemont fled to Belgium to avoid prosecution by the Spanish judiciary. The court said in its ruling that he can remain free.


Most liked

XO Music Fest, Featuring T.I. and Ludacris, Canceled
Then, it was discovered that XO's mystery promoter, Sami Habib, had recently been arrested for a high-end real-estate scam. Organizers teased attractions like foam pits, an indoor skating rink, and an " interactive bounce arena ".

Giant mysterious black sarcophagus found in Egypt
Archaeologists have discovered a black granite sarcophagus in an ancient cemetery deep underneath Alexandria , Egypt . The next step is for researchers to find out what is inside the coffin without damaging it.

Michael Flynn 'eager' for sentencing in lying case, attorney says
Flynn stepped down as Trump's national security adviser in February 2017 and pleaded guilty in December . Federal Judge Emmitt Sullivan told Flynn that he could be sentenced as soon as late October.

Anthony Bourdain earns posthumous Emmy nominations
Interested in Emmys? Add Emmys as an interest to stay up to date on the latest Emmys news, video, and analysis from ABC News. Bourdain, 61, took his life on June 8 while on location in France to record an episode for " Parts Unknown ".

Ontario investigating 3 heat-related deaths
With highs in Toronto of up to 35.4 C, Environment Canada said the early-July heat wave was one of the most extreme in years. Marie-Claude Lacasse said in an email the medical examiner will determine the exact cause of death.

Martin wins Stage 6 of Tour de France, Van Avermaet keeps lead
He was one of eight top Tour contenders to gain some handy time that may prove vital come the Tour finish in Paris on July 29. The Dutchman was seventh going into this stage only 13 seconds behind Van Avermaet but will now be a minute behind.

London police detain Maryam Nawaz’s son for ‘punching PTI worker’
His daughter, Mariam Nawaz, was sentenced to seven years in a case stemming from documents leaked from a Panama law firm. Justice (r) Javed Iqbal said that strict action would be taken against those found creating hurdles in their arrest .

Natural disaster reveals 1,000-year-old Aztec temple
View of the substructure inside the Teopanzolco pyramid in Cuernavaca, Morelos State, Mexico on July 11. The Aztec-era pyramid was built sometime between 1200 and the Spanish conquest in 1521.

Hello beer in corner stores; bye discovery math: Throne speech
They will also increase "supports" for families with autistic children, although few details were provided. The speech pledged to restore Ontario to "once again be the engine of Canada's economy".

Xherdan Shaqiri will have a medical with Liverpool on Friday
The Reds start their new Premier League campaign against West Ham on August 12. The Mirror says Liverpool face competition from Lazio for Shaqiri.

Trump Says There 'Might Be an Escalation' Between US, Iran
Russia, China and the big European powers say they still back the 2015 multinational nuclear deal with Iran , despite U.S. Belgian authorities are also seeking Assadi's extradition over the alleged plot.

Federation Internationale de Football Association urges broadcasters to stop zooming in on ‘hot’ women
Ruby Mae gets the beers in while England play Croatia in the world cup semi-final at the Luzhniki Stadium, Moscow. Addiechi added that it was not a "proactive campaign" but said "we'll take action against things that are wrong".

Blast rocks fuel tanks near Cairo airport (PHOTOS, VIDEO)
While flights have not been affected, some witnesses described the vehicle traffic in and out of the airport as a " nightmare ". A number of local tweets poured in with users claiming to have heard a loud explosion followed by the sounds of ambulances.

Fiat workers 'to strike over Cristiano Ronaldo signing'
The USB union confirmed Thursday it has called a three-day strike from Sunday at the Fiat plant in the southern town of Melfi in protest.

Once criminality of Section 377 goes, so will stigma against LGBTQ
One of the observations made by the top court said , " Section 377 is the infrastructure for denying rights". "The members of the community feel inhibited to go for medical aid due to prejudices against them".