Human, Harish Natarajan wins over AI debating system

Harish Natarajan

To access the competition, the audience was asked to vote for one side or the other at the start of the debate, and again at the end of it. Recent AI beats champions on the Starcraft field. It was the artificial intelligence technology's first live debate in public. About 30 percent of the audience voted against the subsidising of pre-schools.

While the debating system, Miss Debater argued that subsidizing preschools isn't just a matter of finance, but a moral and political duty to protect some of society's most vulnerable children, Natarajan countered that, too often, subsidies function as politically motivated giveaways to the middle class.

"Its rhetorical skills still were not at the level of Harish", Slonim said during an interview following the debate.

"It needs to pinpoint these little pieces of text that are relevant to the topic, that are argumentative in nature, that hopefully support our side of the debate, and then somehow glue them together into a meaningful argument, which is very hard for a machine to do".

Debater also went on to say cite a 2013 study "by the Melbourne Institute of Applied Economic and Social Research", which it said "shows that attendance at preschool has a significant positive impact on later NAPLAN outcomes, particularly in the domains of numeracy, reading and spelling". Project Debater, which isn't connected to the internet, comes up with statements using data from the 10 billion sentences stored in its database, which are taken from newspapers, magazine articles, and academic journals.

Debater also managed to make the audience laugh.

The debate with Harish Natarajan was not Project Debater's first test against humans. "Welcome to the future". He added that the AI's arguments were "nicely phrased and contextualized", and that it could be "quite powerful" when used by humans.

"There is hope behind the technology". In 2011 two Jeopardy! Pushing its AI technology to debate a human became the next problem the company sought to solve, which it started working on in 2012.

"If you think about grand challenges in the past around AI, these were often cases where there was a factual question and a clear victor [and right and wrong answer]", she said. "It's about weighing different options, which is what we face everyday in the real world". For example, personal assistants can help us find directions, play our music or call our contacts.

Project Debater argued we should subsidise preschools because they benefit impoverished populations, create better students, and contribute to lowering crime rates. In 1996, chess grand master Garry Kasparov was defeated in the game of chess.

"Debate is out of the comfort zone of AI", said Slonim in an interview before the event.

Monday's debate, which was organized by nonprofit debate-hosting company Intelligence Squared US, was held in front of an audience in San Francisco's Yerba Buena Center for the Arts.

The demonstration came the same day that President Trump signed an executive order aimed at expanding the development of AI in the United States, although the order was short on details.

Related News:



Most liked

Ex-'American Idol' contestant transported fentanyl, cocaine, heroin, according to indictment
A New Jersey native, Barba was an American Idol hopeful in the same season that saw Jordin Sparks crowned the eventual victor . The group allegedly stored the drugs in a Norfolk apartment, and the documents list several drug deals occurring in late 2018.

Apple sales tumble in China as smartphone market shrinks
While Apple's share of the Middle Kingdom's smartphone dropped, sales of devices from rival Huawei Technologies Co. Apple's October-December shipments suffered a almost 20-percent decline from the same period in the previous year.

The Breaking Bad movie will reportedly land on Netflix, AMC
There isn't much known about the Breaking Bad movie at this point, as numerous plot points are being kept under wraps. It's unclear whether or not the movie will air as one continuous feature, or get chopped into multiple installments.

‘Spyro Reignited Trilogy’ Nintendo Switch Release Possibly Leaked in GameStop Posting
However, the post has since been taken down, but not before fans took plenty of screenshots of the supposed flub. Nintendo's hand-held console has been rumored to be acquiring the classic purple dragon Spyro .

Westbrook, PG Etch Names In Triple-Double History
During Westbrook's streak, the Thunder are 9-1, and he is averaging 19.7 points, 13.2 rebounds and 13.8 assists per game. Go out and compete every night and leave it on the floor, and whatever happens, happens.

Texas couple jailed after children found neglected
Akin said the suspects, who have not been identified, are facing four counts each of endangering a child. A fight between the two is what brought deputies to the rural home, and the man had cuts to his face.

Calls to ban app that allows 'control of women' in Saudi Arabia
Human Rights Watch's Rothna Begum told INSIDER: "Apple and Google have rules against apps that facilitate threats and harassment. This is another example of how the Saudi Arabian government has produced tools to limit women's freedoms.

US Charges Former Air Force Intel Officer With Spying for Iran
Born and raised in Texas, Witt entered on duty for the Air Force from 1997 to 2008 and worked as a contractor from 2008 to 2010. Shortly after joining the military, Witt studied Farsi at the U.S.

Dortmund's flight delayed as Jadon Sancho forgets his passport
Dortmund have arrived in England and will train at Wembley on Tuesday before the first leg of the last-16 tie. England worldwide Sancho forgot his passport and was not allowed on the plane with his teammates.

F1 in 2019: Max Verstappen debuts deceptive Red Bull RB15
At the moment, I am of course very optimistic, but also realistic and I think time will tell how we are going to perform". After five years without championship success, Red Bull is switching from Renault power to Honda this year.

'Screen women for breast cancer every year from 35'
The researchers analyzed that if 35-39 years of old women undergo annual mammograms, then breast cancer could be detected earlier. In its response, NHS England spokesperson assured to consider the possible changes to the screening programme in the review.

Oil gets a boost from Saudi output pledge, declining U.S. inventories
The EIA, however, added a note of caution that US production would be capping oil price gains. Compliance by non-OPEC participants was only 25 percent, however, it said.

Rapper 21 Savage granted bond, to be released: lawyer
Abraham-Joseph has never hid his immigration status from the US government...the continued detention of Mr. The rapper was released on bond Tuesday pending a deportation hearing. "Mr.

Michelle Obama’s Grammy appearance did not impress her mom
I would think all Shields needs to know about Obama's celebrity status is that she is BFFs with Beyoncé . It allows us to hear one another, to invite each other in.

Disney's 'Frozen 2' fires up a fun first trailer
The icy sequel looks to make Elsa (and possibly Anna) superheroes - but it is only a teaser trailer. Snowflakes fall on the screen, while the narrator promises a look at the highly-anticipated sequel.