Confirmed: Raspberry Pi 4 has a USB-C Design Problem

Raspberry Pi 4 Won't Work with Some USB Type-C Cables

Many users also complained that the Pi 4 is not working with all USB-C cables.

As noticed by Tyler Ward, the detection circuitry of the new model Raspberry Pi uses a single shared cc pull-down resistor on the USB Type-C connector which causes it to be misidentified as an audio adapter accessory instead of a device that needs to be powered.

E-marking is a technique which gives a cable a digital signature based on what the cable is going to do.

"I expect this will be fixed in a future board revision, but for now users will need to apply one of the suggested workarounds".

Upton added that he was surprised that the issue did not show up in its testing program, which he claims is "quite extensive".

While basic USB-C cables deploy a single CC line which detects the right amount of current required by the Pi to power the device, the electronically marked cables use two CC connections which make them non-compatible with Raspberry Pi 4. However, it looks like the designers made a crucial error in designing the board that limits which USB-C cables you can use. "Instead of trying to come up with some clever circuit, hardware designers should simply copy the figure from the USB-C Spec exactly", wrote Leung.

"Benson Leung, an engineer at Google and one of the Internet's foremost USB-C implementation experts, has chimed in on the Pi 4's USB-C design too, with a Medium post titled "How to design a proper USB-C™ power sink (hint, not the way Raspberry Pi 4 did it)".

The Raspberry Pi Foundation isn't the only one to have flubbed this up. Incidentally, the new iteration does not have a dedicated power supply port and has to completely depend on USB Type C port. More specifically, it doesn't work with so-called e-marked cables, such as those used on Apple Macbooks and several other laptops.

The Pi 4 is not the first high-profile device to get the USB-C spec wrong. The second mistake is that they didn't actually test their Pi 4 design with advanced cables. "I get it, the USB-C cable situation is confusing and messy, and I've covered it in detail that there are numerous different cables", he continued. However, several modern-day chargers are able to deliver far more power owing to newer Fast Charging standards.

An easy workaround is to buy a non-e-marked cable or charger.

Fortuitously, it doesn't damage the Raspberry Pi 4, and it doesn't create any fire hazard.

Related News:



Most liked

USWNT’s Rapinoe on MSNBC: I spoke with Infantino about equal pay
And I think this team really understands, and is so prideful that we do carry with us other people when we step out on the pitch. As a gay woman, Rapinoe has a strong distaste for Trump's rhetoric and wasn't shy to reveal her true feelings on the matter.

USD Spikes Lower as Dovish Fed Powell Sets Stage for Rate Cuts
She tells Powell that it was essential that he and other Fed official refuse to "submit to these high pressure tactics". The president has been Powell's harshest critic, and in recent days hinted about his authority to demote or fire him.

Bill Addresses 'Unacceptable' Gender Pay Gap in US Soccer
After the final, the crowd at the Parc Olympique Lyonnais in Lyon chanted "equal pay" during the post-match celebration . Women's Soccer team not to visit the White House in protest to President Trump's administration.

MLB All-Star Game scoreboard has rough night
For the National League, it will be the Dodgers Hyun-Jin Ryu on the hill, who boasts a 10-2 record and an MLB-leading 1.73 ERA. The Tribe's Carlos Santana, who competed in Monday's Home Run Derby, will start at first base in his first Midsummer Classic.

IBM completes $34B acquisition of Red Hat
Red Hat CEO Jim Whitehurst and the wider leadership team "are all staying with us for a good long time", Rometty said. Also, Red Hat's CEO Jim Whitehurst will join IBM's senior management team and report to CEO Ginni Romerty.

Nintendo Switch Lite announced, launches September 20 for $199
To find play mode compatibility information for specific games, please refer to the product packaging or Nintendo eShop. Wireless controllers can still be connected to Switch Lite. "More to come on there, but that is the intention".

Manchin introduces bill pressuring US Soccer to increase women's pay
The Women's World Cup started in 1991, so if you're keeping count, the US has won half of the eight tournaments so far. The victory is the US women's national team's fourth Women's World Cup title and second in a row.

Warriors waiving Shaun Livingston
After playing for eight teams over the first nine years of his career, Livingston found a home with the Warriors in 2014. Livingston was not expected to be with the Warriors next season, either because he would retire or be waived.

UK's Labour party backs staying in European Union in call for second referendum
But he said Labour, in its 2017 election manifesto also committed to opposing a no-deal Brexit and the Conservative Brexit plans. On Friday he called on Labour members to sign a declaration, piling pressure on it to become the "party of Remain".

Justin Bieber vs Tom Cruise 'to be biggest earning UFC fight ever'
Previously, Justin took to his social media account to ask Tom Cruise for a fight in the octagon, however, at a later date, Mr. Once again Justin has nominated him for the bottle cap challenge after saying that he wished it was Tom Cruise's head.

Nicki Minaj Drops Out Of Saudi Arabia Concert After Facing Backlash
The Human Rights Foundation issued a statement last week, calling for Minaj and other performers to pull out of the show. The " Megatron " rapper was originally supposed to headline the festival on July 18.

US, China move to restart trade talks
He had previously threatened to put punitive duties on an additional $300 billion in Chinese exports. But differences remain between the world's two largest economies. "We want a good deal".

Boeing reports no new orders for 737 Max amid grounding
Airbus (AIR.PA) said it delivered 389 aircraft in the first half, confirming a figure first reported by Reuters on Friday. Airbus' popular A320 planes compete with Boeing's 737s in the single-aisle segment, which comprise most aircraft orders.

Broken Harts… Amy’s in hiding as dad bans show
She continued: "Once this is all done, we will have the best friendship you've ever seen in your life". The outing comes as the Flack headed into the villa to announce the shock elimination of two couples.

NBA Board of Governors approve coaches' challenges for 2019-20 season
George has been a key figure in both tampering charges, trade demands and player-to-player recruitment in the last three years. The penalty for attempting to challenge without a timeout is a technical foul and no challenge to the call will be given.